Bhagavad Gītā Chapter 6, Verse 34: Krishna to Arjuna — Dhyāna-Yoga

Bhagavad Gītā 6.34Chapter 6 · Dhyāna-Yoga · Krishna → Arjuna · anuṣṭubh
चञ्चलं हि मनः कृष्ण प्रमाथि बलवद् दृढम् ।
तस्याहं निग्रहं मन्ये वायोरिव सुदुष्करम् ॥
cañcalaṃ← cañcala(3 verses)nominative neuter singular noununsteady, fickle, restless hi← hi(70 verses)for, indeed, because (particle) manaḥ← manas(41 verses)nominative neuter singular nounmind (lower mind), the inner organ of perception kṛṣṇa← kṛṣṇa(14 verses)vocative masculine singular nounKṛṣṇa; black, darkattested in commentariesadvaitaइति कृष्यतेः विलेखनार्थस्य रूपम् pramāthi← pramāthin(2 verses)nominative neuter singular nounagitating, churning (from pra- + √math + -in)attested in commentariesadvaitaच प्रमथनशीलम् प्रमथ्नाति शरीरम् इन्द्रियाणिviśiṣṭādvaitaप्रमथनशीलम्bhaktiप्रमथनशीलं देहेन्द्रियक्षोभकमित्यर्थःadvaita-bhaktiशरीरमिन्द्रियाणि bala← balavat(3 verses)nominative neuter singular noun(bala + -vat: strength)vad dṛḍham← dṛḍha(5 verses)nominative neuter singular nounfirm, fixed (past participle of √dṛṃh)attested in commentariesviśiṣṭādvaitaअन्यत्र चरति
tasy← tad(305 verses)genitive neuter singular nounthat (distal demonstrative); also 3rd-person pronounattested in commentariesadvaitaसंबुद्धिःviśiṣṭādvaitaस्वाभ्यस्तविषयेषुbhaktiमनसोऽपि निग्रहं निरोधं सुदुष्करं सर्वथा कर्तुमशक्यं मन्येadvaita-bhaktiनिवारणं जीवन्मुक्तिरित्युच्यतेāhaṃ nigrahaṃ← mad(383 verses)nominative singular nounI, me (1st person pronoun stem); also: to rejoice (verbal root) manye← √man(25 verses)present indicative 1st person singular verbto think, regard, consider (verbal root)attested in commentariesadvaitaवायोरिव यथा वायोः दुष्करो निग्रहः ततोऽपि दुष्करं मन्ये इत्यभिप्रायःviśiṣṭādvaita। मनोनिग्रहोपायो वक्तव्य इत्यभिप्रायः।advaita-bhaktiवायोरिव vāyo← vāyu(6 verses)genitive masculine singular nounwind; the wind-god Vāyur iva← iva(17 verses)like, as if su← su(11 verses)good, well; auspicious prefixduṣkaram← duṣkaraaccusative neuter singular nounhard to do (dus- + kara)
spokensingle-voice recital; rendered via IndicF5 conditioned on a Sanskrit reference clip
meaning

The mind is restless, turbulent, powerful, and stubborn, Krishna; I think restraining it is as difficult as restraining the wind.

Bhāṣyakāra purports

  • Śaṅkaraadvaita

    The mind (manas) is by nature cañcala (restless) — not merely unstable but actively pramāthin (an aggressor that seizes and subjugates body and sense-organs). Śaṅkara adds that it is balaval (potent, not restrainable by any means) and dṛḍha (hard as a thorn-rope, indivisible like a tāntanī-serpent). Therefore Arjuna declares nigraha (absolute cessation) of such a mind to be suduṣkara (exceedingly difficult) — as impossible as imprisoning wind in the sky.

    divergence: Śaṅkara: 'pramathyaśīlam, deham indriyāṇi ca vikṣipat sat paravasīkaroti … dṛḍhaṃ tantunāgavat acchedyam' — the mind grasps and subjugates, and is impenetrable like a thorn-snake.

  • Rāmānujaviśiṣṭādvaita

    Even in objects long rehearsed (anavarata-abhyasta-viṣayeṣu), the mind cannot be held in one place by the puruṣa's own effort — it forcibly (balāt) seizes him and wanders elsewhere. Rāmānuja compares restraining the mind toward an object contrary to its conditioning to trying to stop a great wind (mahāvāta) with a fan — it is suduṣkara because the mind's svabhāva is misdirection, not quiescence.

    divergence: Rāmānuja: 'tad-viparītākārātmani sthāpayituṃ nigrahāṃ pratikūla-gateḥ mahāvātasya vyajanādinā iva suduṣkaram' — restraint in a direction contrary to the mind's current is like pushing back a great wind with a fan.

  • Madhvadvaita

    Madhva grounds Arjuna's complaint in Vyāsa's own Yoga-scripture: because the mind is cañcala (unstable), yoga's steadiness (sthiti) cannot arise without abhyāsa (practice) and vairāgya (dispassion) — of that there is no doubt (na saṃśayaḥ). The difficulty of nigraha is thus doctrinally confirmed by śāstra-citation, not merely by Arjuna's experience.

    divergence: Madhva cites Vyāsayoga: 'manasaś-cañcalatvād-dhi sthitir-yogasya vai sthirā / vinābhyāsān-na śakyā syād-vairāgyād-vā na saṃśayaḥ' — without practice and dispassion, stable yoga is impossible.

  • Vallabhaśuddhādvaita

    Arjuna perceives that the yoga of sama (equanimity) described by Kṛṣṇa is impossible precisely because the mind is cañcala (restless by nature). Vallabha glosses the wind-simile spatially: just as restraining wind that churns in open sky (ākāśe dhodhūyamānasya) into a pot is impossible, so too the uncontainable mind cannot be dammed. The verse thus names the failure-point of all autonomous sādhana, making Puṣṭi-mārga's prasāda (divine grace) the only viable ground.

    divergence: Vallabha: 'yathākāśe dodhūyamānasya vāyor-ghaṭādiṣu nirodho duṣkaras-tadvat' — restraining wind churning in the sky into a vessel is as impossible as restraining such a mind.

  • Śrīdharabhakti

    Śrīdhara enumerates four qualities that make the mind ungovernable: cañcala (restless by inherent nature), pramāthin (agitator of body and sense-organs), balaval (not conquerable even by deliberate reasoning), and dṛḍha (impenetrable, bound fast by viṣaya-vāsanā). Restraining it entirely — as one cannot stop wind from churning in the sky into a jar — is sarvathaiva aśakya (wholly impossible).

    divergence: Śrīdhara: 'pramāthi pramathana-śīlaṃ dehendriya-kṣobhakam … dṛḍhaṃ viṣaya-vāsanānubadhhatayā durbhedam … tathā tasya manaso nigrahaṃ suduṣkaraṃ sarvathaiva kartumaśakyaṃ manye'.

  • Madhusūdanaadvaita-bhakti

    Madhusūdana begins with the word 'Kṛṣṇa' itself as a signal: by addressing the Lord as kṛṣ (one who draws away the sins of devotees), Arjuna implicitly appeals to the only power that can restrain the unrestrainable — thus the very name is a petition. He then glosses pramāthin as that which makes body and sense-organs helpless (vivasha-kara), balaval as that which cannot be turned away by any upāya, and dṛḍha as a tāntanā-pāśa (a coiled serpentine snare). Even after jñāna arises, prārabdha-karma sustains the citta's oscillations; therefore yoga-nigraha of mind in the full sense is impossible even for a jñānin still bound by prārabdha.

    divergence: Madhusūdana: 'yasyāḥ saṃpādanena sa yogī paramo mataḥ … prārabdhakarmabhogāya jīvataḥ puruṣasya … citta-cāñcalye yogena tan-nivāraṇam-aśakyam-ahaṃ svabodhād-eva manye'.

Sūtrakṛt-Gītā · v1.0 · gita.ekrasworks.com